Augean Stables

From Jeff Tucker:

For more than a century, even dating back to 1883, the civil service has grown and grown without check from the elected branch, either the presidency or the legislature . The bureaucracies have ballooned from a few to 450 or so. The bloat and absurdities have grown too. Get this: no one has ever known what to do about it. Not Coolidge, not Hoover, not Nixon, not Reagan, not Clinton, no one. No president has been able to crack this nut.

The only reforms ever to have made it through are those that make the administrative state bigger, never smaller. Countless cabinet secretaries have come and gone, always with the intention of making a change but leaving saddened, demoralized, outwitted, outgunned, and ultimately devoured. No president has seriously taken on this problem because they simply did not know how. The unions are powerful, the intimidation from the deep institutional knowledge is overwhelming, the fear of the media as been powerful, and every single president comes to power vaguely feeling threatened by the intelligence agencies. The industries that have captured every single agency were also far too powerful to unseat or control.

This combination of institutional inertia has blocked serious reform for a full century. No one has dared. No one has even had a theory or strategy about what to do about this problem. It had become so terrible that most people in politics have simply surrendered, like homeowners who know there are rats in the basement and bats in the attic but long ago gave up trying to fix the issue.

All this time, the American people have felt themselves ever more oppressed, weighed upon, taxed and regulated, spied upon, brow beaten, and otherwise overwhelmed. Voting never made any difference because the politicians no longer controlled the system. The bureaucracies ruled all.

But now we have a chance.  It may be our last, because right now, in the paraphrased words of John Adams, we have men worthy of the time:  a president who has a burning desire to make the changes necessary, an associate of towering intellect and inherent power who may be able to execute that change, and the subordinates who are just as willing to make those changes with the necessary authority (in the shape of presidential appointees), and others (the twenty-something hackers and geeks) who have the knowledge, skills and the tools to be able to root out the corruption and deadweight of accumulated bureaucracy and perverted, un-American policy.

7 comments

  1. 80% of everything has to go.
    80% of ALL gov’t employees need to do.
    80% of ALL gov’t spending needs to stop.
    80% of ALL US parasites need to go.

    After all that occurs, then and only then, might we be a free people.

    Until then, we will continue to be victims in wait, hoping against hope, that we, each of us, does not become a victim of the overbearing state. We outlaws.

    signed,
    The Raging Patriot.

  2. I agree on the problem, I disagree it is as is intractable as your source states. If the line items on the budget are eliminated, they will go away.

    The issue is that it has never been a priority for the Republicans and the Democrats actively want it bigger because they actively consider the federal employees to be allies (and they are correct).

    DOGE and anything like that is nice, but any real change has to be driven by Congress. Unfortunately, making those changes are not even favored by all Republicans, and essentially none of the Dems. Change that and the system changes become easy, don’t change that and the system changes are not going to happen.

    So we will get some changes around the edges, and that is good, but Congress is where we need to drive this.

    1. The President has to start vetoing spending bills, and the budget bills that generate that spending.
      If that induces a paralysis in the government – TFB!

    2. The President has to start vetoing spending bills, and the budget bills that generate that spending.
      If that induces a paralysis in the government – TFB!!

  3. Bluntly:

    This is our last, best chance, and it is a flat out miracle that we have it.

    The alternatives are succumbing to a collectivist panopticon hell, or war.

    I was pretty firmly in the “we’re not going to be able to vote our way out of this” camp. Now I give it a strong “maybe”. The thing deserves its best chance.

Comments are closed.