From Bill Hoge, in discussing POTUS’s plan to close over one hundred I.R.S. offices:
“Why do we need taxpayer assistance centers? Why are our taxes so freaking complicated that people with graduate degrees have to fork over thousands of dollars to their CPAs because the tax code is so convoluted that only a full-time tax nerd can figure them out?”
That’s a really good question. My favorite story about the I.R.S. is the one where someone called a few of these “assistance centers” because he had a problem with something on his return. Every single one of the centers gave a different answer to his question — in other words, the I.R.S.’s own staff couldn’t navigate their way through the code.
I remember Mr. Free Market’s tale of paying his income tax in Hong Kong, back when he lived there (pre-CCP takeover). Every December he would go to the local tax office with the HK equivalent of an IRS Form 1099 from his employer (which stated only that his salary was $x — there were no deductions or withholdings whatsoever). He would then write out a cheque for 5% of that amount, the clerk would stamp his 1099 as proof of payment… and that was it.
Frankly, I would have no problem with paying a flat (and fixed-forever) tax rate of 7% on that basis. (“Why 7% and not 5%, Kim?” Because unlike Hong Kong, we need to pay for things like naval carrier groups and interstate highways, which I like and support). I would even support paying 7% of my Social Security, as long as everybody — including welfare recipients — paid the same tax rate on gross income, without exemption (or deductions). Only if you have skin in the game should you be allowed to vote on the subject, e.g. raises to the rate, which I’d want protected by a Constitutional amendment anyway.
Feel free to explain to me why I’m wrong. Good luck with that.