Here’s something from Collectors which may seem to carry too high a price (even for them), but really isn’t: 3-Gun Set Belonging to Col. S.B. Sightler ($17,500).
Now I have no idea who the late Colonel Sightler is, or how much his personal collection may be valued by a collector. What I do know is that the collection is as follows:
Parker DHE side-by-side 20ga shotgun:
(not the actual gun, but a representative sample thereof)
Underwood M1 Carbine:
And Winchester 62A pump-action .22 rifle:
Now here’s my point. Each of the above guns is, by itself, supremely droolworthy. And their average sale prices, individually, reflect that. Depending on condition, a Parker DHE 20ga typically runs about $10,000-$14,000 (I’ve seen higher); Underwood M1 carbines can fetch $1,500-$1,600; and a Winchester 62A about $1,200-$1,500.
Adding that up, it comes to around sixteen grand for the three guns, if bought individually. In that light, the $17,500 that Collectors is asking for the collection doesn’t seem that extreme — even allowing for their normal (inflated) markup.
And one last thing. Given that these guns were owned by an ex-military man, I’m willing to bet that all three guns — even the little Winchester gallery gun — are in fine condition, which makes them a safe purchase.
If I were a collector and in the market for some decent guns, I’d be sorely tempted. The provenance is just a bonus.