Smith & Wesson have made several excellent revolvers over the many years of the company’s existence; in fact, they’ve made so many that the blizzard of differently-numbered models is bewildering, especially to an Older Man Of Little Brain And Much Confusion like myself.
Nevertheless, that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t look on any specific model with a jaundiced eye, oh no. Rather, we should regard each of them with extreme pleasure… and which brings us to this particular model, the 19 (from Merchant Of Death Steve Barnett) — which many regard as one of the very best:
I guess the only question to be asked is: “Would this be an acceptable gun for the Governor’s BBQ party?”
My answer would be: “Of course it would. It’s absolutely gorgeous.”
My own taste would run instead to the blued 6″ version (because blue is less show-offy, and the 6″ barrel handles the .357’s recoil better than the shorter 4″):
…but it wouldn’t matter, because it’s still the same damn fine revolver.
And yes, I know: the K-framed Mod 19 may not stand up to heavy shooting of the .357 Magnum cartridge, the N-frame (model 27) being perhaps better-manufactured for that purpose.
But honestly — and I say this as an owner of a K-frame Model 65 in the same chambering — exactly how much intensive .357 Mag shooting can one handle before there’s an aching wrist in the picture?
I just think the K-frame revolvers fit better in my hand than the beefier Ns; and that is one of my major criteria in buying a handgun, any handgun. And for those of an historical bent, it should be pointed out that S&W has been making their K-frame revolvers since the late 19th century.
Discuss.